Hadith books belonging to Bukhari and Muslim are known as Sahiheyn (two sahih). Bukhari, in particular, is generally accepted as the most solid work after the Qur’an. Well, is it really like this? Isn’t there really any erroneous information in Buhari? In this video, although it may seem not very important to some people at first, this information is questioned through a very, very carefully chosen example. The most practical way to show that a hadith is erroneous is to show that it is CONSEQUENTIAL with another hadith. In this case, it turns out that one of the two hadiths is wrong. However, hadith advocates imagine that they answer many contradictory hadiths with various interpretations. For example: One hadith abrogated the other (changed its decree); The hadith declares one general and the other special decree; There is an attempt to find between contradictory hadiths with various interpretations, such as one hadith expressing perseverance and the other expressing license. However, when there is a contradiction about a historical event, no method of interpretation can be introduced. In this video, “Who is the first lady who died after Rasul?” sample is selected. In the sahih of Muslim, in the sahih of Bukhari and in the work titled historyus sagir by Bukhari, the rumors about this information were examined and the reason for the contradiction between them was questioned. .
Subscribe to YouTube Channel